Extremely 99% Invisible-coded
3.0 stars
This was a decent, if not cursory, look into how product/building/etc testing has evolved through the years. Most of the examples weren't new to me, but maybe a decades-long testing nerd isn't the target audience. This would probably fare better with a precocious high schooler in a robotics club, or a kid wanting to know more about the people who design the products they use. Basically the same audience as the 99PI podcast.
What I'd have liked to see more of is explanations of what happens when testing doesn't go well, or are ignored, or otherwise fails. There's a section near the end that discusses trying to account for unintended consequences, such as the failure at Vajont Dam in 1963. But every time they Davies wrote about the ways Boeing made their airplanes robust in the 1990s, I couldn't help think about the changes to the corporate structure, and …
This was a decent, if not cursory, look into how product/building/etc testing has evolved through the years. Most of the examples weren't new to me, but maybe a decades-long testing nerd isn't the target audience. This would probably fare better with a precocious high schooler in a robotics club, or a kid wanting to know more about the people who design the products they use. Basically the same audience as the 99PI podcast.
What I'd have liked to see more of is explanations of what happens when testing doesn't go well, or are ignored, or otherwise fails. There's a section near the end that discusses trying to account for unintended consequences, such as the failure at Vajont Dam in 1963. But every time they Davies wrote about the ways Boeing made their airplanes robust in the 1990s, I couldn't help think about the changes to the corporate structure, and the middle-management-driven culture, that led to the repeated failures of the 737 MAX and other recent disasters. There's a few lines about this at the end of the book, but this feels like the more pressing issue that deserves more of the spotlight.
If you're interested in more of these examples I'd recommend the Well There's Your Problem podcast; it looks at testing and engineering failures from a broader (albeit leftist) perspective, and unfortunately there is lots more of that these days.