Elder Race - BookWyrm

Nils Müller liest reviewed Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Science-Fantasy mal anders

5 stars

Elder Race ist tatsächlich mein erstes Buch von Adrian Tchaikovsky - und warum zum Teufel habe ich so lange damit gewartet, mal etwas von ihm zu lesen? In dem eher kurzen Roman erzählt der Autor eine doppelte Geschichte: Da ist eine in Ungnade gefallene Prinzessin, die versucht, mit der Hilfe eines mysteriösen Magiers der "Elder Race" ein gefährliches Monster zu besiegen und so bei ihrer Familie Anerkennung zu finden. Dann ist da aber auch noch ein Anthropologe der Menschheit, der den Forschungsposten auf einer weit abseits gelegenen Kolonie betreut und schon seit Jahrzehnten den Kontakt zur Erde verloren hat.

So erzählt Tchaikovsky dieselbe Geschichte aus zwei Perspektiven, die unterschiedlicher nicht sein könnten, und es trotz aller Versuche auch nicht schaffen, wirklich miteinander zu kommunizieren. Ein für mich bisher vollkommen unbekannter Take für das etablierte Genre der Science-Fantasy. Lesen.

essteeyou@bookwyrm.social reviewed Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Review of 'Elder Race' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

Absolutely blasted through this in two days.

I really loved that it wasn't a huge novel, but now I've finished it I find myself wishing it was so much longer.

I guess I need to read some more Tchaikovsky even sooner than I was already planning to.

Eric Wagoner 📚 reviewed Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Started with an interesting premise, ended deeply satisfying

5 stars

She is a fourth daughter of royalty with no hope of advancement in station, determined to invoke the promise of aid given to her ancestor generations ago by a powerful wizard when her mother refuses to engage a demon threatening the kingdom.

He is a long-lived exo-socialogist, sent to observe these people but not interfere. He broke that directive once before, many years ago, and now another of them has shown up at his outpost door...

I've never seen a story play with Clarke's Third Law ("Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.") like this before. Each chapter alternates POV between the two main characters, so it is half science fiction and half fantasy. Sometimes the same events are told both ways. The story is interesting on its own, but told this way it also becomes a lesson on empathy and understanding.

It surprisingly also became a story about …

She is a fourth daughter of royalty with no hope of advancement in station, determined to invoke the promise of aid given to her ancestor generations ago by a powerful wizard when her mother refuses to engage a demon threatening the kingdom.

He is a long-lived exo-socialogist, sent to observe these people but not interfere. He broke that directive once before, many years ago, and now another of them has shown up at his outpost door...

I've never seen a story play with Clarke's Third Law ("Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.") like this before. Each chapter alternates POV between the two main characters, so it is half science fiction and half fantasy. Sometimes the same events are told both ways. The story is interesting on its own, but told this way it also becomes a lesson on empathy and understanding.

It surprisingly also became a story about severe depression, persevering through grief and trauma, methods of self care, and how mental anguish can appear from the POV of both those suffering and those around them.

And that will always endear this story to me.

ceoln reviewed Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Review of 'Elder Race' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

A fast, fun, rewarding read.

This kept me reading from the first page to the last. What's happening isn't at all a puzzle, unlike some other books that use the same general concept (some of which I now want to go back and re-read). The way the high-tech protagonist's depression was dealt with was fascinating to me, and not one I've seen before; and having clinical depression myself, I found it plausible and relatable. And the relationship(s) between the high-tech protagonist and the indigenes who see him as a wizard were done well, feeling genuine on both sides.

Very recommended!

Pentapod reviewed Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Review of 'Elder Race' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

This short novel is a fun cross between science fiction - junior anthropologist Nyr who is the only remaining member of a research expedition to observe a long-ago established and then lost colony - and a fairy tale fantasy - fourth-eldest princess Lynnesse sets off on a quest to win the help of the mythical wizard in order to save the land. The story is told from both viewpoints, so we alternately see Nyr as a depressed, despairing, second-class anthropologist and an incomprehensible, immortal, powerful wizard of legend; and the world they are on and the monsters they battle alternately as the stuff of fairy tales and the stuff of science. Even the language they use to communicate translates unexactly, so Nyr has literally no way to describe himself that doesn't translate into Lyn's language as "magician" or "sorceror" even though he is trying to say "scientist" or "academic" or …

This short novel is a fun cross between science fiction - junior anthropologist Nyr who is the only remaining member of a research expedition to observe a long-ago established and then lost colony - and a fairy tale fantasy - fourth-eldest princess Lynnesse sets off on a quest to win the help of the mythical wizard in order to save the land. The story is told from both viewpoints, so we alternately see Nyr as a depressed, despairing, second-class anthropologist and an incomprehensible, immortal, powerful wizard of legend; and the world they are on and the monsters they battle alternately as the stuff of fairy tales and the stuff of science. Even the language they use to communicate translates unexactly, so Nyr has literally no way to describe himself that doesn't translate into Lyn's language as "magician" or "sorceror" even though he is trying to say "scientist" or "academic" or similar.

The whole thing is a fun, very readable exploration of Clarke's Law that any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. It was a quick read and I could easily have read more, but I enjoyed it.

Will reviewed Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

The POV Switches Make This Book

4 stars

The story overall isn't all that great, but the contrasting worldview of the two POV characters gives it something special.

cblgh@bookwyrm.social

rated it

Nov. 21, 2021